|
|  | Director: David Hugh Jones
Actors: Richard E. Grant, Joel Grey, Ian McNeice, Saskia Reeves, Desmond Barrit
Studio: Turner Home Ent
List Price: $14.98
Buy New: $5.40
as of 11/23/2009 18:45 CST details
You Save: $9.58 (64%)
New (40) Used (12) Collectible (1) from $5.40
Seller: mediathrill
Rating:  155 reviews
Sales Rank: 231
Format: Closed-captioned, Color, DVD, Full Screen, NTSC
Language: English (Original Language)
Rating: NR (Not Rated)
Region: 1
Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
Picture Format: Pan & Scan
Number Of Discs: 1
Running Time: 95 Minutes
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.2
Dimensions (in): 7.5 x 5.6 x 0.6
MPN: TRNDT8161D
ISBN: 0780623746
UPC: 053939816129
EAN: 9780780623743
ASIN: 0780623746
Theatrical Release Date: December 5, 1999
Release Date: November 7, 2000
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Condition: Brand New! Factory Sealed! US Retail DVD! Customer service is our #1 priority. Thank you for choosing MediaThrill.
|
| Customer Reviews:
Showing reviews 16-20 of 155
 Without a doubt Closest to the original Dickens Classic December 20, 2008
Mark Myword
2 out of 3 found this review helpful
It has been estimated that there have been over 1,000 versions (since the first 1910 silent one) of this timeless classic, and I know that a lot of people credit the Alistair Sim version as being most faithful to the original text--while factually it is far-and-away among the LEAST faithful to the Dickens' tale.
I don't say that to disparage Sim's version as I find it a thoroughly enjoyable and well done classic. That said, however, its divergence from the original text begins with the title "Scrooge" instead of the actual name "A Christmas Carol". It changes Belle's name to Alice, it has her ending up as a lonely spinster working in some poorhouse for sick elderly instead of happily married and mother to the children Scrooge might have called his own; Fan is anything but "little" and the abandoned boy at school is hardly a "boy"... the list of other deviations goes on and on for this alleged "truest to the original" version; but that is NOT what this critique is about--it's about Stewart's version; yet I felt it necessary to mention that to make my point.
I am a Dickens purist, and while I enjoy ALL of the versions of this classic (and the Sim, and Reginald Owen and George Scott versions are among my favorite --as is the Mr. Magoo version among the many animated ones), THIS one (with Patrick Stewart is far and away the very BEST if you want to see it as close to the way Dickens wrote it as possible.
That said, it DOES have its senseless deviations. For one inexplicable thing the producers saw fit to change the name of his sister Fan, to "Fran" (I really think that is the silliest thing they did and by far the most egregious infidelity with no justification beyond using a more common name). At least she IS a little girl... and Scrooge a little boy at the time. The book DOES begin with a brief snippet from Marley's funeral but only to get in the lines about Marley being "dead as a doornail" followed by a reference to it's not being the "deadest bit of ironmongery" (directly from the text)... then quickly changes to the scene in Scrooge's counting house, with Cratchit busily at work in his little tank while the mercenary Scrooge watches greedily.
From this point on the movie follows the actual story with remarkable accuracy. It even shows the ghost of Christmas Present as a MALE!!! as opposed to the Politically Correct penchant of so many producers to make one of the Spirits a female (despite the FACT that the Ghost of Christmas Present refers to his 1800 plus BROTHERS). Joel Grey is perfect as the diminutive Spirit who looks both old and young at the same time. The Spirit of Christmas Present also is great, and takes Scrooge to all those places, (the lighthouse, the ship at sea, down in the "bowels" of the Earth, to the almshouses and prisons), and later we actually see him AGE... something NO other version I've seen depicts. After his frightful trek with the Ghost of Christmas yet to Come (NOT the Ghost of Christmas Future--never mentioned in the book)... he more accurately reacts... we see him go to church (not shown in any other)... and his pacing in front of the nephew's house before dashing for the door. Little things like this make it just perfect among ALL versions. -- OH! And Cratchit actually DOES live in a hovel... truly a poor residence, and is skinny and looks the Cratchit we envision while reading the tale. And again unlike all other versions, depicts Bob going upstairs to say one last farewell to Tiny Tim who is obviously waked in his bed after his demise--another thing NO other version I know of shows.
Okay... I'm not going to go on any further and doubt many will have read this far; but I was only too happy to critique this version simply because I'm always excited when I see a movie that, unlike most, is truly faithful to the actual text. Beyond the irksome moniker of "Fran" and a few changing of words to a more modern lexicon hither and yon... this made for TV movie is without peer as a screen adaptation of the most filmed and most timeless Christmas Classic ever put to pen--or on screen. No doubt -- Five stars and a big thumbs UP! Loved it!
best version December 19, 2008
K. A. James (Crete, IL United States)
0 out of 1 found this review helpful
Patrick Stewart is so great in this version of a Christmas Carol. A must for all fans of this classic tale.
Pat Stewart and Xmas Carol December 18, 2008
Barry S. Ziegler (Nokomis Fla)
We watched the movie on TNT last night. I'm now on line buying a copy. We thoroughly enjoyed this version. We are also fans of G.C.S. in his 1984 version. Bravo to both George and Patrick!!
 Perhaps the most over-acted Scrooge ever... December 11, 2008
Ian Walters
2 out of 6 found this review helpful
I'm a big fan of Patrick Stewart - But this is easily his "jump the shark" moment. The most overacted, one-dimensional Scrooge imaginable. I always thought the '38 Reginald Owen version was the 'bad' one. Once this one came out, the '38 version doesn't seem so bad anymore.
Still, the '51 version with Alastair Sim is the standard, in my humble opinion.
Magic of Christmas December 4, 2008
Patriot
Not many christmas films add that magic of emotion,Patrick Stewart`s role as Scrooge is an inspired performance.It seems this adaption is true to Dicken`s novel,an amazing fusion of special effects and christmas wonder to meaningful characters that have universal appeal.We watch this every year and fight back the tears by the end.Merry Christmas everyone!
Showing reviews 16-20 of 155
|
|
|
Return to Math.com | |
