Customer Reviews:
Showing reviews 1-5 of 17
 Minus 148 Degrees November 11, 2009
Steve_in_TN (TN USA)
Others have covered the details so I'll skip that. This is not a very well known mountaineering book, probably because of its age and not its content, but it's a fantastic read that I found impossible to put down.
 What's the point? September 29, 2009
Anthony M. Frasca (East Setauket, NY USA)
0 out of 1 found this review helpful
Minus 148 is a narrative/memoir/journal of the first winter climb of Denali, the preferred Native American name of Mt. McKinley, the highest peak in North America (McKinley never even saw the mountain and it was a typical political naming. Call it Denali). Why in winter? Because no one had ever done it before.
Yawn.
It is a tale of bush pilots, of climbing glaciers, of fierce winter storms and of a harrowing effort to survive.
However, the climb begins with death. Early in the expedition a member descends into a crevasse while trekking unroped on the Kahiltna glacier, he would not survive. But, that won't stop the team. They pushed ahead and left the corpse to be frozen and transported when the expedition ended. The author did preempt the death by carefully detailing the historical recklessness of the dead climber (Jacques Batkin). They did have a lengthy discussion about it.
Bravo.
The rest of the book is just a detailed narrative of the effort to push to the summit of Denali and the subsequent need for rescue. They did make it to the top, in darkness. All they could see after a hard won summit were the far off lights from Anchorage.
Rah!
Predictably, the weather turns ugly, and by Alaska winter standards that's saying something. The summit team gets stranded for a week by a blizzard and seeks refuge in a snow cave. When the weather finally clears and a rescue is underway the climbers are irritated, yes that's what he wrote, IRRITATED that people would risk their own lives to effectuate a rescue of these hapless nomads.
I would pass on this book. There are many other better mountaineering books out there.
minus 148 October 31, 2008
Ed Joyce
0 out of 8 found this review helpful
Book was good but text was missing from maybe 20 pages of the last chapter.
 A book ahead of its time October 12, 2008
Scott Guile
1 out of 1 found this review helpful
I am not going to rehash the plot here, I'm sure others have done so and you can get that in some capacity from many sources. The author was on the expedition which this book is about, and it was a bold one to say the least; the first winter ascent of Mt Mckinley. He does a great job inviting us onto Mt McKinley (it was not Denali in 1967, at least not in the public mind) and this is a quick and pleasing read. However he does not interweave as deftly the history and personal story lines that have taken the genre to new places in the past decade or so. Granted Art wrote this in 1969 at which time he'd sworn off expeditions -- largely as a result of holing up in snow cave in a hurricane at 18,000 plus feet for 8 days - so the books that I'm used to reading from adventure writers simply feel more modern. Regardless of this I would highly reccomend this read, and I would also pair it with Forever on the Mountain by James Tabor; about the Wilcox expedition on the same mountain a mere 3-4 months after the first winter ascent (which ended up changing the rules for how Mountains would be climbed in general - not from the mountaineering standpoint, but rather from the standpoint of how gov't officials approved and approached expeditions). For any armchair expeditioner -- such as myself -- the literature on McKinley is essential. This is a mountain that can be every bit as evil and unforgiving as the nastiest Himalayian peak, the weather and the relief are actully in most cases at least equal. Donavan's book is certainly a great read. I bought the paperback reprint, but if I had a do-over I'd look for an early edition as I suppose they must be out there.
Pretty Good Description of Event December 23, 2007
Nolan W. Bailey (Rowlett, TX United States)
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
I'm not sure, but I may have been one of the pilots on the C-130 that helped to coordinate the rescue of the team off of Mt. McKinley. Rescue 489 sounds like one of the 17th Troop Carrier Squadron's aircraft. And, I recall dropping (parachuting) a couple of radios on the emergency frequency to a climbing team that we helped rescue. The aircraft commander and I are discussing this particular rescue as "I speak."
As I recall, the person from the expedition that was talking to me was very very reluctant to leave the climb, finally asking what it would cost. When the team was assured that there would be "no cost," things did change... :-)
On the rescue that I'm describing, perhaps the one covered in this book, the Army Huey helicopter had difficulty landing at such a high elevation, and carrying out such a load. I watched as the helicopter lifted off, and it had to dive down toward the base of the mountain to get into more dense air, and to gain associated lift. On the way back to the airport, we slowed the C-130 down, and lowered the flaps, so the Huey helicopters could fly on each wing tip...
Showing reviews 1-5 of 17
|
